Bring the Noise: Two ExcerptsBy Simon Reynolds
March 12, 2011
AGAINST THE GRAIN: Thinking about the Voice in Pop
(originally published in Melody Maker,November 20, 1993)
Most rock-crit doesn’t have much to do with rock as music. Usually it’s amateur sociology, or Eng-Lit analysis of lyrics, or biography/gossip. But even those who do grapple with music-as-music seldom get much purchase on the Voice, beyond saying a particular voice is ‘great’ or ‘original’, or gushing superlatives.And that’s because the Voice is a mystery, defying analysis.It’s hard to say why one voice leaves you cold and another pierces the marrow of your soul, gets in your pants, fits you like a glove.