Loot boxes remain a disputed category in gaming regulation. The key point is that randomness alone does not determine whether a loot box qualifies as gambling. An assessment should consider what users receive, whether the rewards can be transferred between users or systems, and whether they have economic value outside the game itself.
Transferability is the primary consideration in this context. It is the ability to transfer or exchange digital items or related value between users/players. To this end, it is essential to note that transferability is not a legal test, but one of the factors that has to be considered during the assessment.
What Transferability Means in a Loot Box System?
In the broader context, transferability describes the extent to which digital assets can be moved, exchanged, or otherwise transferred beyond the account where they are initially stored. This capability seems to be simple, yet it has several distinct forms in the loot-box system.
Account-bound rewards represent one end of the spectrum: they remain tied to the account where they were obtained and cannot ordinarily be transferred to another account. User-to-user transfers allow players to move items between accounts through supported mechanisms. Marketplace trading provides another route, potentially allowing items to be exchanged for in-game currency. External trading involves transactions outside the game's official infrastructure, where items may be exchanged for other assets or real-world money. These arrangements are not interchangeable. Transferability therefore describes a range of possibilities rather than a single technical feature.
Economic and Legal Value of Digital Rewards
In this instance, it is essential to note that a digital reward can have substantial gameplay utility without retaining monetary value. For instance, it may unlock some features or enhance a character. These benefits may be important for a user, but they are not necessarily equivalent to economic value, as the applicable rules determine it.
The distinction becomes more important when a reward can be sold or exchanged for real-world money through external channels. Actual transactions may provide evidence that an item has economic value beyond its gameplay function. The key question is not simply whether players want a particular item, but whether its features and available exchange routes establish economically relevant value. However, the legal significance of that value depends on the applicable national rules and the circumstances of the particular mechanic.
How Secondary Markets Provide a Signal of External Economic Value
Secondary markets provide important evidence about whether digital rewards have gained any value outside the gameplay. When players regularly exchange items, these deals may even shape a separate part of the market around their usefulness and desirability. Even the cases when trading is done informally may signify that digital items have gained value. The origin also matters in this case.
Operator-enabled transferability refers to exchange mechanisms provided or permitted within the game, such as an official marketplace. Third-party trading takes place through external channels. Although these arrangements may overlap, they can have different practical and legal implications. Operators may restrict transfers through their own systems, but they do not necessarily control transactions conducted independently on external markets.
There are many factors to consider in this case since neither situation clearly establishes that a reward represents a gambling prize, as the applicable rules define it. The authorized bodies typically conduct a broader analysis, taking into consideration the reliability of price signals, nature of exchange, correlation between the exchanged item and a wider gaming environment, etc. It is also essential to consider separately whether the applicable rules recognize the delivered value. Even though secondary markets can provide the value that a certain item retains, it doesn't equate to the governing statute and the conditions adopted within the certain system. The latter have a decisive importance. To this end, Soft2Bet's investigation provides a broader and more detailed assessment.
Closed-Loop vs Open-Value Reward Structure
There is a useful way to assess the transferability that digital items may have in the loot box system by distinguishing between a closed-loop structure and open-value reward. Under the closed-loop structure, rewards remain within the defined game setting or account. They may support many options: progress features, customization, in-game functionalities, etc. However, players can't use an ordinary mechanism to transfer these assets outside the system to an external market or otherwise convert them into real-life money. Overall, the value of such items is closely linked to continued participation in the system.
In contrast, the open-value structure allows a broader asset circulation and conversion. Gained rewards may be transferred to other users, exchanged through some marketplace, or traded on external platforms. These transfer routes make the item's value less dependent on the original gameplay function it is closely linked to, yet more dependent on the external circumstances. Still, the said distinction is rather analytical rather than absolute. The authorized bodies examine the item's entire economic and functional context. These include the assessment of how it was obtained, what players can do with it within the specific system and beyond, as well as how the mechanics fit into the wider game.
Dutch Case on Transferability
The Dutch 2018 case illustrates the importance of assessing transferability. The local regulator paid attention to the transferability of the in-game items and the insertion of money. In certain cases, the regulator noted that rewards with economic value alongside random outcomes fall under the Dutch gambling rules.
However, on 9 March 2022, the Netherlands' highest administrative court, the Raad van State, reached a different conclusion in a case involving FIFA Ultimate Team packs. The court found that obtaining and opening the packs did not constitute a standalone game of chance because the packs formed part of a broader skill-based game. It also considered how the packs were obtained and used, as well as the relatively limited trade on unofficial external markets. The ruling did not establish that transferability is irrelevant; rather, it showed that transferability alone does not determine whether a particular mechanic qualifies as gambling under Dutch law.
What Are Final Practical Implications for Reward-System Design
In the case of loot boxes, transferability should be assessed alongside the reward's functionality and economic value. An important distinction is whether rewards are account-bound, transferable between accounts within the same system, or available for exchange through external markets. The available exchange routes also matter, including whether an item has an observable real-world price or can be converted into money. Finally, the assessment should consider which transfer mechanisms are provided or controlled by the operator and whether independent third-party trading exists outside the game's infrastructure.
When conducting the detailed assessment, legal analysis always follows the reward's economic structure and practical operation, without being limited to the analysis of the asset's visual representation and similarity with other assets. Only a broader assessment is a credible option to identify the nature of the item and its value alongside the analysis of the applicable rules.









